Have I heard that somewhere before?

Where do a writer’s words come from? From within them of course – but from the outside world too.

I swear I don’t do it on purpose – but I am as guilty as any writer of the occasional bit of word theft. I consciously try not to do it – and I would never nick a whole paragraph or anything as outrageous as that.

But there are times, when I look back over what I have written that perhaps the odd phrase here or there rings a distant bell – and I realise that’s because, one way or another – I have lifted it from something else I read or heard or saw years before.

Magpie_robinLook – I’d say it was inevitable really – because I don’t just adapt from art – I adapt from life – someone might say something to me in passing in the pub and ten years later those same words are coming out of the mouth of a fictional character on one of my pages.

So it’s perhaps not surprising that the writer’s magpie mind picks up shiny things from other works of art and resets them later in their own work.

arden-king-lear-old-editionWant to see an example of it happening? Just look at any of the annotated student versions of Shakespeare’s plays – an Arden edition for example (do they still do those?) You get a third of each page of play – then two-thirds of notes telling you where each line, each phrase, each word, was used before or since.

So here’s the first paragraph from one of my short stories called The Runner – it was, and is, an important story for me first because it’s a good one and second because it won an award called the Bridport Prize which is quite a big competition in the UK.

One morning I remember I woke up and one of us was crying. And for a baffled, anxious moment I couldn’t work out whether it was me or my soon to be ex-wife.
Hollow, vacant sobs, lost under the duvet. It was me, but it could have been either, could have been both, united in the terrible grief of division.

I mean – that’s me, I wrote that. But there are echoes here and there

409px-ElvisCostello1979Here’s Elvis Costello – the only Elvis who really mattered for men and women of my generation. A sound bite of lyrics from his late period masterpiece ‘I Want You’. See the phrase in there which looks familiar?

Your fingernails go dragging down the wall
Be careful darling you might fall
I want you
I woke up and one of us was crying
I want you
You said “Young man I do believe you’re dying”
I want you

But there’s more – another source I think. Look at the opening paragraphs from Martin Amis’s The Information:

InformationCities at night, I feel, contain men who cry in their sleep and then say Nothing. It’s nothing. Just sad dreams. Or something like that … Swing low in your weep ship, with your tear scans and your sob probes, and you would mark them. Women – and they can be wives, lovers, gaunt muses, fat nurses, obsessions, devourers, exes, nemeses – will wake and turn to these men and ask, with female need-to-know, ‘what is it?’ and the men say, ‘Nothing. No it isn’t anything really. Just sad dreams.’

If I were to go through any of my work with a fine tooth comb I would find examples like that dotted through it I think. Some kind and careful readers have found examples for me in Song of the Sea God. Either on a macro level where they point out other books or movies which it resembles in terms of theme or on a micro level where they recognise a form of words, a turn of phrase.

None of us works in a vacuum I suppose is the message.

Song of the Sea God visualDon’t forget if you get a moment to take a look at my book Song of the Sea God.

You can look inside to read the first few pages free and download a free Kindle sample for UK readers here. And for readers in the USA here.

6 thoughts on “Have I heard that somewhere before?”

  1. Christ, I think it’s a bit like one of your previous posts where you talked about the ideas we come up with. They’re out there in some form or other, and as you rightly say, we don’t live in a vacuum. I don’t know if you’ve ever watched the magician Daniel Brown, but he shows how strongly influenced we are by even just snippets we hear and glimpses of things we see, so even when we don’t realise we’re absorbing stuff we do! Great post as always!

    1. Thanks Val – I think writing, like painting, music and all sorts of other art, involves the unconscious as well as the conscious mind and so sometimes it’s only when you go back and analyse what you’ve been doing that you can work out where it all comes from. Sometimes not even then of course.

  2. Gosh… with the Internet nothing is original anymore. Every time I come up with a new concept, name or thought I Google it and it’s already THERE. We are all influenced by what we’ve read and absorbed. It’s inevitable. I loved what you wrote by the way.

    1. Thank you Pinky, how kind. I think you are right that it’s harder to be truly original the more that is written. On the other hand, each piece of work you produce is uniquely yours – whatever may have gone into it in terms of influence.

  3. Nice blog topic Chris! I think it’s hard to be always original in an over-used international language like English. But maybe it doesn’t matter what little bits we borrow from the present or past but how we spin them out with our own inimitable voice. After all, no two magpie nests are ever exactly the same, are they? Not that I’ve done the field research on this point!

Leave a Reply to Marjory McGinn Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.